THE FLUTE NERD blog

5 Mistakes Returning Flute Players Make

Coming back to the flute after years away? Here’s what’s actually getting in your way, and it’s not what you think.

So. You’ve picked up your flute again after several years away. Maybe even decades. You were excited. Ready to come back to something you used to enjoy. You put the flute together, and you tried to ignore the fact that it felt surprisingly ungainly in your hands. And when you played it… well. It certainly wasn’t the sound you were expecting. If you even got a sound at all.

And I imagine it wasn’t long before somewhere in the back of your brain, a tiny little voice started speaking up. Something like: What were you expecting? You’re too old. Too late. You should have started sooner. Should have never stopped. You’re rubbish.

Oh, I know that voice well.

And today we’re going to prove it wrong.

Because here’s what it’s missing: you are coming back to the flute after years, after life, after whatever it was that took you away. And that’s OK. None of this is evidence that you’ve failed, or that you don’t have talent. It is, in fact, proof that you love this instrument. You love it enough to come back.

So let’s look at five mistakes I see almost every returning flute player make — why we make them, and how to move past them — so you can get back to what you actually want to be doing: playing the flute.

First, A Bit About Me

I know these five mistakes very well. Because I’ve made every single one of them myself.

I quit the flute. For eight years.

And I didn’t quit because I stopped loving it. I quit because the pressure of music school got under my skin and forced me to take my life in a slightly different direction. A one-year break turned into eight, and for most of that time I was very good at telling myself a story I now hear from students constantly: maybe I’m just not disciplined enough for the flute. If I were really talented, I’d still be playing.

Eventually, I realised that the flute was something I really missed and I wanted to make time for it again. This time, though, I was going to come back to it with joy rather than pressure.

Which is, of course, easier said than done. It wasn’t long before I found myself making the very same mistakes we’re about to talk about. So here we are.

Mistake 1: Trying To Pick Up Exactly Where You Left Off

This is going to be a hard truth to swallow, but no matter how long it’s been since you played regularly — be it decades, years, or even just a couple of months — you are not going to be where you left off.

Let that sink in for a moment. Be angry about it if you need to. Pause and punch a pillow or have a little scream. Do whatever you need to do.

Feel better? Great. Because here’s why this is actually good news.

Yes, it will feel rusty. Yes, your sound is going to be a struggle. You might find that your muscle memory is patchy, your note reading a bit slower, your embouchure completely confused about what it’s supposed to do. That’s all completely normal. It’s what happens after time away.

But, and this is important, none of it is lost. It’s just dusty. The skills are still in there. The muscle memory is still in there. It comes back, and it comes back a lot faster than if you were starting from scratch as a complete beginner. You are not starting from zero. You are starting from experience. That’s a completely different thing.

Here’s another thought worth holding onto. You are not the same person you were when you put that flute down. That person is gone. Which is actually good. The player you were when you put the flute down had bad habits, was probably more naïve, and was likely playing to appease a teacher, a parent, an exam, an ensemble, someone else’s expectations rather than their own happiness.

Today, you are wiser. You understand things better. You have lived a whole life in between. And hopefully you are coming back to the flute because you want to. Because you love it. As something just for you. And when you’re playing for that reason, it changes everything about how you practise. You’re not rushing through things to pass an exam or get approval. You’re not performing for anyone. You get to actually enjoy the process.

When players come back to the flute, they often arrive with all these expectations of sounding just like they did when they stopped, and that critical little voice in the back of your head starts dealing out “shoulds” and “shouldn’ts” left, right and centre. You should be able to play this. You shouldn’t sound so bad.

But everything comes back in time. And even better: you’re in a different place now, which lets you approach everything from a completely fresh perspective. That is something to hold onto. Not something to apologise for.

Mistake 2: Treating The Break As Evidence Of Failure

This is one that tends to catch people by surprise. There is a weird, pervasive sense of guilt that often comes with taking a break from the flute. Like you abandoned something, or a part of yourself. Like the break was a character flaw, proof that you weren’t committed enough, disciplined enough, serious enough.

And so every struggle as you try to get back into things can feel almost like righteous punishment. Like your flute is mocking you for having been so weak as to need a break.

But there are so many reasons people step away from the flute. Maybe you were a teenager when you last played, and teenagers quite reasonably have a lot of other things competing for their attention. Maybe you had a family, and that ate up all of your free time. Maybe you had an illness, an injury, a job that needed everything you had. Maybe the pressure of playing well just got too much and you needed to step away to protect yourself. All of these are valid reasons for a break. Every single one of them.

And sometimes — a lot of the time, actually — that break gives you something you couldn’t have gotten if you’d just powered through. Perspective. Distance. The chance to come back on your own terms, for your own reasons, with a completely different relationship to why you’re doing this.

So if you find the guilt creeping up on you: you didn’t fail. Life happened. Life always happens. You had jobs and relationships and grief and kids and chaos and probably some very compelling television. None of that makes you a quitter. It makes you a human being.

The important part is that you’ve come back. And for yourself. That’s pretty cool, so hold onto it.

Mistake 3: Treating Old Bad Habits As Personality Traits

Have a listen to these phrases and tell me if any of them sound familiar.

“I’ve always had a bad tone.” “I can’t play high notes.” “Vibrato is beyond me.” “I’m rubbish at scales.” “I can never figure out my embouchure.”

These things sound like facts. They feel like facts. But they’re not. They’re stories you used to tell yourself. Sure, they probably came out of something you were genuinely struggling with, but they were struggles that existed in a very specific context: you were a different person, with different pressures, different time constraints, a different relationship to your instrument. Those habits and limitations weren’t who you are. They don’t define you.

Here’s a personal example. When I was at university, I was constantly told I had a tight embouchure. I knew it was a problem, but fixing it properly would have meant starting almost from scratch, going back to basics and letting myself sound genuinely terrible for a while. I didn’t feel like I had time for that. I had a degree to get through, recitals to perform, exams to pass. So I pushed through it, and while it improved slightly, the tight embouchure stuck around.

But when I came back to the flute after eight years (and my sound was, predictably, not great) I felt that same old story creeping in. It’s just because I have a bad embouchure.

Then I remembered: I had no deadlines, no exams, no recitals. So why not actually do what I should have done back then?

So I did. And it didn’t take nearly as long as I expected, because I wasn’t fighting years of freshly-reinforced habit. The habits, both good and bad, had softened over the break.

The things I used to think were just part of who I was as a player? They were just where I was at the time. They weren’t permanent. And they’re not permanent for you either. You get to come back and reinvent yourself. You get to become the player you always wished you could be, because this time you have the wisdom, the patience, and none of the pressure that was getting in the way before.

Mistake 4: Not Having A Decent Working Instrument

So far we’ve been mostly in the land of mindset, but here’s a very practical mistake that’s worth flagging, one that seems almost too obvious to mention, and yet.

Please make sure you have a decent working instrument as you get back into playing.

You would be surprised how many returning players are attempting a comeback on a flute that’s been sitting in a cupboard for ten, 20, or 30 years. Chances are that instrument is going to need a little TLC. Even if it’s never left its case, there will likely be issues. Corks can shrink. Mechanisms stiffen over time. Springs weaken. Pads deteriorate. A flute that’s been sitting untouched for years is just not going to play the way it should.

Here’s why this matters so specifically for returners. Beginners don’t know what the instrument is supposed to feel or sound like, so they assume things are normal. But you, as a returner, do know how it’s supposed to feel. So when something sounds wrong, you’re going to take it personally. You’re going to assume it’s you. And you can spend months blaming your embouchure for something that is literally just a leaking pad. I have seen this happen. Please don’t let it be you.

Before you really get stuck back into playing, give your flute a spa day. Take it to a reputable repair technician. Get it cleaned, oiled, and adjusted. Ask them to check the pads, the cork, and the mechanism. It’s one of the best investments you can make in your return.

And for those of you who no longer have your old flute and need to find something to get back into the swing of things with: nobody wants to spend a lot of money on something they’re not sure they’ll stick with, so starting with something more affordable makes sense. But please, please do not buy a flute from Amazon if you can possibly avoid it. Those instruments are very cheap for a reason, and they will make your life harder than it needs to be. Find a decent beginner instrument, new or secondhand, from a reputable dealer. Or if you’re borrowing a flute from a friend, offer to take it to a repair shop first. They’re letting you borrow their instrument. The least you can do is make sure it actually plays.

Mistake 5: Going It Alone Because You Feel Too ‘In Between’

This last one goes something like this: I’m not a beginner. I know things, I have history with this instrument. But I don’t really know how to start getting back into the swing of things. Private lessons feel like they’re for kids, right? And I’m probably not good enough to join an ensemble or a workshop.

So you end up self-teaching. And there is nothing inherently wrong with that. We’re adults, we like figuring things out for ourselves. But it can get overwhelming very quickly. At some point you’ve watched countless tutorials, received contradictory bits of advice, and are somehow more confused than when you started.

This is so common for returners. You fall into a gap, this forgotten middle ground, between beginner resources that feel too basic and intermediate spaces that feel too intimidating. Most learning platforms are designed for one or the other, which means returners often end up falling through the crack between them.

But being “in between” is not a problem. It is not a level you need to graduate out of before you’re allowed to have support, or community, or guidance. It is a level. And you deserve exactly the same kind of encouragement at this level as anyone else does.

There’s also a practical problem with learning in isolation: you have no feedback loop. No one to tell you what you’re doing well, and what might actually be getting in your way. Without that, it’s very easy to accidentally rebuild old bad habits. And it’s also very easy to start beating yourself up about where you think you should be, without anyone around to offer a bit of perspective.

Finding support, whether that’s a teacher, a group lesson, an ensemble, or a community, helps you understand what is completely normal for a returner, and what is actually worth working on. And it means you’re not doing all of this alone.

There are more spaces out there for adult returners than ever before. Find the one that fits you. And find it before you feel ready, because here’s a secret: you will never feel ready. That’s not a reason to wait. That’s just what the voice in the back of your head does.

Final Thoughts

So how many of these mistakes do you recognise? And honestly, I don’t love calling them “mistakes.” They’re patterns. Ways of thinking that are natural, understandable, and very human. Identifying them isn’t about beating yourself up, it’s about understanding where you are right now, so you can figure out what you actually need.

You are not behind. You are not too late. You are not too broken, too rusty, or too in between. You are a flute returner. And that means you get to do this completely differently this time with everything you know now that you didn’t know then.

That is not a disadvantage.

That is, genuinely, a superpower.

Ready to Stop Going It Alone?

If Mistake 5 hit a little close to home, the Flute Nerd Lab might be exactly what you’ve been looking for.

The Lab is a learning community built specifically for adult flute players, and specifically for people coming back to the flute after time away . Every month we dive deep into a topic together, with exercises, discussions, live Q&As, and a community of people who absolutely get it. No judgment, no gatekeeping, no “you should already know this” energy. Just good, nerdy flute fun.

👉 Join the Flute Nerd Lab for free here and come find your people.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Picture of Alexandra Petropoulos

Recent Posts

Flute Tips & Deals

Sign up to my newsletter for lots of tips, inspiration, and exclusive discounts!

The Flute Nerd Lab

A learning platform and community for flute players who want to level up their playing!